Former Governor Snyder made a backroom deal to allow Enbridge to build an oil tunnel through the Straits of Mackinac but did not require it to do so. With over 95% of the oil in Line 5 coming from and returning to Canada, it makes little sense for Michigan to build a tunnel for Canadian oil. A tunnel is a bad idea on many levels. Enbridge experts testified, and independent experts agree that Line 5 can be shut down without spiking energy prices.
Enbridge is trespassing on the Bad River Band reservation in Wisconsin. A judge ordered its pipeline to shut down there by 2026, but Enbridge is appealing the ruling to delay any shutdown.
Now, Enbridge is abusing its power to continue pressing for a tunnel. It is pushing Canadian officials to wrongfully enforce a 1977 pipeline transit treaty to keep Line 5 open indefinitely.
A tunnel would take several years to plan and build, all while keeping the Great Lakes at risk from the current Line 5 (imagine an 80-year-old Line 5 before a tunnel is ever completed).